Used Electronics Recycling
Closed Loop Foundation commissioned a report to provide a view of the e-waste landscape within the United States in order to understand types and quantities moving into the waste stream today and in the future.
With the increased adoption and use of electronic and electrical devices has come the increased generation of used equipment as products are replaced by newer models and older technologies become obsolete or no longer meet the expectations of the consumer. Electrical and electronic equipment (EEE) no longer useful to its first owner may still have considerable value, so market solutions have evolved with the waste stream to capture this value.
The goal of this report is to provide a complete overview of the used electronics management landscape within the United States to understand:
- The types and quantities of materials that are currently and will be moving into the waste stream in the next five years;
- What type of programs are in place currently and how effective they are; and
- How changes in consumer desires and behavior, device technology, governmental regulation, and practices in the electronics and recycling industries will impact the effectiveness of recycling programs and demands in the next five years. This analysis is then used to identify the opportunities available, and provide solutions to address the challenges identified to support the development of a resilient used EEE management system.
Media Coverage
The Telegraph
‘I made £20,000 renting out my clothes’
After a backlash against ‘fast fashion’, renting…
Inc Magazine
Top Female Founders on the One Move That Made Their…
Sometimes, it involves an unexpected pivot. Other times,…
Drapers
DAI Raises £1.7m in Crowdfunding Campaign
Womenswear brand Dai has raised $2m (£1.73m) from…
Refinery29
The Resale Industry Is Changing — Here’s What to…
One of my favorite feelings in the world is the burst…
Elle
3 Women Making Waves In Their Fields Share Their Biggest…
From overcoming challenges to making positive changes…
Vogue Business
This Vogue Editor Rented Her Whole Wardrobe For A Weekend…
How do you fancy getting your hands on the largest…
The New York Times
Purging Old Clothes? Here’s How to Responsibly Donate…
If you have piles of old clothes and shoes languishing…
Financial Times
Fashion for Rent: The New Style of Ethical Dressing 
Don’t buy it when you can hire it! How sharing apps…
Inc Magazine
Why This Founder Chose to Change Her Whole Business…
For Days founder Kristy Caylor had to make a tough…
Vogue Business
Circular Fashion: Exciting to Talk About, Tough to…
If fashion wants to be circular, it needs to master…
Forbes
Evrnu’s Recycled Waste Fiber Launches Today, And…
It’s much-maligned by many fashion industry stakeholders…
Business of Fashion
Rental Platform By Rotation Raises $3 Million
Investors are eyeing the peer-to-peer model in rental…
Cleaning the rPET Stream
A study, commissioned by Closed Loop Infrastructure Fund, to identify recycling system interventions that reduce the cost of processing post-consumer PET.
Less than 30% of the PET used in bottles and jars is recovered in the US, and just 6% is re-used as rPET in new bottles. Yet PET is the most common resin type used in plastic packaging and the most universally accepted plastic in US municipal recycling programs. Recycling infrastructure for post-consumer PET is also the most mature. How can we address the stark under-performance of PET recycling through investment in solutions that provide long-term benefits to the system overall?
Ideally, demand pull from end users would encourage the recovery and reprocessing of post-consumer recycled PET; yet the market is constrained by the ability of suppliers to offer rPET at prices that can compete with virgin PET resin. If we are ever going to be able to grow the rPET market, we need better solutions that drive efficiencies throughout the process, improve the cost structure of producing rPET, and enhance the material’s overall value.
Statistics
More than 6 billion pounds of PET bottles and containers are generated each year
Less than 30% of the PET used in bottles and jars is recovered in the US
6% is re-used as rPET in new bottle
Our Work
In an analysis conducted by Closed Loop Partners with RRS, we have identified a suite of interventions that would greatly improve the cost structure of rPET and benefit MRFs, reprocessors, and end-users.
If implemented nationally, we could increase the recycling rate of PET by 6% and close the loop on nearly 80 million pounds of PET bottles each year – without putting a single new cart on the street.
Focusing on bottle-to-bottle processes, we identified several interventions that effectively improve yield from residential curbside collection by more than 20% and lower costs of rPET processing by 10%.By targeting action and investment, MRFs, reclaimers, reprocessors, and end-users could realize value for themselves and across the system.
THE COST DIFFERENCE BETWEEN RPET VS. VIRGIN PRODUCTION PROCESSES:
- Virgin: Virgin material is produced at scale by combining raw material inputs (PTA, MEG) in a polymerization process. At the time of the study, the estimated average cost to produce virgin PET was $0.60-0.65 per pound.
- RPET: Post-consumer recycled PET must travel from consumer to MRF to reclaimer/reprocessor to end user – at each stage there is potential for yield loss and inefficiency. At the time of the study, the estimated average cost to produce virgin PET was $0.52-0.56 per pound.
FACTORS THAT ARE DRIVING COSTS FOR RPET:
- Quantity: Consumer access to, and participation in, convenient recycling determines supply of PET. Supply is not influenced by price or demand; rather, supply is a function of municipal and state policies that determine material recovery, and consumer behavior.
- Quality and Yield of Pet Bales: In non-Bottle Bill states where PET is generally recovered through curbside collection, PET bales out of MRFs have sold for, on average, ~$0.17 per pound, national average (picked up). Bottle Bill bales typically command a premium of $.05 to $.15 per pound over curbside.
- Cleaning and Sorting: Mechanical processing of the PET bale, and the subsequent conversion to flake, drives costs by an estimated average of $0.19 per pound. The many contamination / yield issues are partly a result of MRF inefficiencies in sorting, but also partly result from design decisions made by brand owners that are counter-productive to the recycling process.
- Conversion of Flake to Pellet: The estimated average cost of this process is $0.10 per pound.
- Inconsistency of Supply: In addition to inelastic (i.e., not affected by pricing) volume of material collected, the quality of rPET can vary with little warning. The variability can make it difficult for end users to maintain a consistent quality specification without adapting the process or blend of materials being used.
- Volatility of Commodity Prices: RPET is typically purchased on the spot market. Price volatility prevents suppliers from being able to invest in capital expenses to keep up with the latest technology or expand capacity.
WE HAVE DETERMINED A NUMBER OF PROVEN INTERVENTIONS THAT WORK:
- MRF Sorting and Quality Control: this includes installing optical sorters and robotics equipment, and implementing best management practices
- Flake to Resin/Perform: installing equipment that would bypass the pellet stage, going from flake directly to blend with virgin resin or to perform.
- Brand Commitment to APR Design Guidelines: implemented by end users/brand owners
- Brand Procurement Strategies: this includes pricing to minimize volatility and long-term purchase agreements, negotiated between the end-user and reprocessor
- Chemical Depolymerization: installing/operating new plant to produce like-vigin PTA and MEG monomers
- Byproduct Market Development: for non-PETmaterials (e.g. PP, PE) would incentivize MRFs to improve quality of PET bales, and other commodities
Research and analysis
Glass Recycling Research
Investing in glass clean-up systems at material recycling facilities (MRFs) offers higher value commodities and significant savings for the entire system.
As more municipalities transition to single-stream recycling, glass is arriving at recycling facilities (MRFs) in larger volumes, taxing the limits of aging equipment. The resulting material is more contaminated, making it difficult for downstream processors and manufacturers to use. Glass prices are lower too, driving down profitability and offering few downstream options for MRFs. As a result, more glassends up in landfills.
Across the country, municipalities and MRFs are spending more than $150M a year to dispose of single-stream glass. The problem is likely to get worse as markets continue to decline. As a result, more municipalities and MRFs have chosen to remove glass from their recycling programs in recent months. If the trend continues, the system will recover less and less of the glass generated each year, despite the fact that manufacturers can save significant costs and energy using recycled glass. All stakeholders – from municipalities and MRFs to processors, manufacturers, and brand owners – need a more efficient and cost-effective solution to handle single-stream glass.
Our Work
Closed Loop Foundation’s glass study was conducted with support from HEINEKEN USA in July through December, 2016. Our research team interviewed industry stakeholders, including MRF operators, equipment providers, consultants, glass processors, and end users.
Additional data and research included in this report was obtained from interviewees, Glass Packaging Institute, RRS, and US EPA. Data on MRFs provided by Governmental Advisory Associates, Inc., 2016-2017 Database on Material Recovery Facilities and Mixed Waste Processing Facilities in the U.S., copyright 2016.
Media Coverage
The Telegraph
‘I made £20,000 renting out my clothes’
After a backlash against ‘fast fashion’, renting…
Inc Magazine
Top Female Founders on the One Move That Made Their…
Sometimes, it involves an unexpected pivot. Other times,…
Drapers
DAI Raises £1.7m in Crowdfunding Campaign
Womenswear brand Dai has raised $2m (£1.73m) from…
Refinery29
The Resale Industry Is Changing — Here’s What to…
One of my favorite feelings in the world is the burst…
Elle
3 Women Making Waves In Their Fields Share Their Biggest…
From overcoming challenges to making positive changes…
Vogue Business
This Vogue Editor Rented Her Whole Wardrobe For A Weekend…
How do you fancy getting your hands on the largest…
The New York Times
Purging Old Clothes? Here’s How to Responsibly Donate…
If you have piles of old clothes and shoes languishing…
Financial Times
Fashion for Rent: The New Style of Ethical Dressing 
Don’t buy it when you can hire it! How sharing apps…
Inc Magazine
Why This Founder Chose to Change Her Whole Business…
For Days founder Kristy Caylor had to make a tough…
Vogue Business
Circular Fashion: Exciting to Talk About, Tough to…
If fashion wants to be circular, it needs to master…
Forbes
Evrnu’s Recycled Waste Fiber Launches Today, And…
It’s much-maligned by many fashion industry stakeholders…
Business of Fashion
Rental Platform By Rotation Raises $3 Million
Investors are eyeing the peer-to-peer model in rental…